I.
SERVICE OF SUMMONS AND COMPLAINTS--UNIVERSITY OR STAFF MEMBER AS
DEFENDANT
II.
SERVICE OF SUMMONS AND COMPLAINTS UNRELATED TO THE UNIVERSITY
III. APPEARANCE AS
WITNESSES
IV. LAND CONDEMNATION
CASES
I. SERVICE OF SUMMONS AND COMPLAINTS--UNIVERSITY OR STAFF MEMBER
AS DEFENDANT
When legal action is taken against the University and/or
University staff in their capacity as employees, the plaintiff
must officially serve a copy of the summons and the complaint
upon the named defendants.
University employees must not accept service of summons and
complaints on behalf of the University or The Regents. The
Code of Civil Procedure specifies that the proper persons to
be served on behalf of the Regents are the Secretary or
General Counsel of The Regents, the President of The Regents
(the Governor), and the Chairman of the Board of Regents.
Attorneys in the Office of the General Counsel, as officers of
The Regents, also can accept service on behalf of The Regents.
Improper acceptance of service may result in considerable
embarrassment and possible detriment to the University.
Service upon the Secretary of The Regents results in an
efficient referral of the pleading to this office for
appropriate action and thereby lessens the possibility of a
default.
When University employees are asked to accept service of
summons on behalf of The Regents, they should immediately
refer the sheriff or other process server to the Office of the
General Counsel if there is any question as to why service
cannot be accepted locally.
If an individual University employee is also named as a
defendant in the lawsuit, the employee may accept service of
summons on his or her own behalf but should make it clear that
this acceptance cannot be on behalf of The Regents. Employees
who accept service on their own behalf in connection with a
suit against them by reason of employment by the University
should notify the Office of the Controller & Business Services
Director immediately to ensure that their
interests are fully protected. The Controller will refer this
matter to the Office of the General Counsel.
II. SERVICE OF SUMMONS AND COMPLAINTS UNRELATED TO THE UNIVERSITY
Service of summons and complaints upon University employees
involved in legal actions unrelated to the University may be
made directly to the individual or by leaving a copy of the
summons and complaint with a person "apparently in charge" of
the office or place of business where the intended recipient
works.
When left with the person "apparently in charge," that person
must be informed of the contents by the process server.
Thereafter, a copy of the summons and complaint must be mailed
to the recipient's business address to complete the services.
A summons should be accepted by a supervisor or other person
in charge only for those under his or her immediate
supervision or for a co-worker at that geographic location,
and the supervisor or co-worker should give the summons to the
intended recipient upon that person's return. If the person
does not work at the particular location, the process server
should be informed. If the process server still insists upon
leaving the summons, the University has no duty with respect
to the summons. If an employee does not have a permanent base
of operation, then valid service cannot be made under this
provision.
III. APPEARANCE AS WITNESSES
Cooperative Extension staff members are subject to involvement
in lawsuits involving program-related disputes, and in many
cases staff members are subpoenaed to provide records, to give
depositions, or to appear as witnesses in court. It is
Division policy that Cooperative Extension staff refrain from
volunteering to serve as witnesses in legal actions.
Cooperative Extension is a tax-supported organization and
therefore should not take sides in civil suits. Also,
Extension work requires voluntary cooperation of clientele,
and such voluntary cooperation would be jeopardized if
Extension staff members acted as witnesses for one side in a
lawsuit. When called upon to give advice, staff should be
alert to and avoid possible involvement in court cases. The
Office of the General Counsel can advise as to the nature of
depositions, trials, and other legal proceedings.
When giving testimony for a deposition or at a trial, the
staff member should testify truthfully about the facts based
upon personal knowledge. The best practice is to listen
carefully to the question asked and answer only that question.
There is no need to volunteer information not asked for unless
it appears that the answer would be unclear without such
additional information. The staff memeber should never guess
or give an answer that cannot be substantiated.
A. Subpoena
The process by which the attendance of a witness is
required is the subpoena. It is a writ or order
directed to a person and requiring his or her attendance
at a particular time and place to testify as a witness.
It is the policy of the Division that subpoenas be
accepted when served.
It may require the person to provide any books,
documents, or other things under the person's control.
Such a subpoena is called a subpoena duces tecum.
When a subpoena is served for staff to appear to
testify, it may be either as an expert witness or a
non-expert witness. Policy for each situation is set forth
below.
B. Expert Witness
A Cooperative Extension Advisor or Specialist who is
not a party to the action and is served a subpoena to
testify at a trial or to give a deposition primarily as
to any expert opinion he or she holds on the basis of
his or her special knowledge, skill, experience,
training, or education, qualifies as an expert witness
and is entitled to receive reasonable compensation for
the entire time required to travel to and from the place
where the court, or the taking of the deposition, is
located and while required to remain at such place
pursuant to the subpoena.
When subpoenaed in an expert capacity, the Advisor or
Specialist may choose to take vacation leave during the
time required and seek compensation as an "expert
witness." The Advisor or Specialist should appear as
required and after the testimony, request the court to
fix the expert witness fees for his or her compensation.
In requesting the fees, the computation of daily
consulting fees set forth in section APM-664 of the
Academic Personnel Manual may be used as a guide
unless the individual has more relevant knowledge of
prevailing rates.
Staff members may appear only as impartial witnesses.
The staff member should make it clear that he or she is
giving testimony as an individual and not as a
representative of the University. It should be
understood that the testimony may be as helpful to the
defendant as it is to the plaintiff. Staff members may
not volunteer to serve as an expert witness for a fee
other than that specified above when served with a
subpoena.
If the testimony of an Advisor or Specialist is only
factual and does not require use of his or her
expertise, such as expressing a professional opinion, it
does not qualify the individual for compensation as an
"expert witness."
C. Non-Expert Witness
When served with a subpoena to appear at trial or for
deposition or with a subpoena duces tecum, the person
subpoenaed is entitled to witness fees for each day's
actual attendance at trial or deposition of thirty-five
dollars ($35) a day and mileage actually traveled, both
ways, at twenty cents ($0.20) per mile. (These are
current rates and are subject to change.) If the
witness requests the appropriate payments of one day's
fee and mileage at the time the subpoena is served and
the server fails to pay the fee, the subpoena is not
valid. In criminal cases, the witness is not entitled
to the fee until after appearing as a witness, and then
only if the court so orders. If served with a subpoena
or subpoena duces tecum, County staff should immediately
notify the County Director and specialists should notify
the Statewide Special Program or Project Director. When
appearing as a non-expert witness, staff should not take
leave. The daily fee should be submitted to the
Regional or Budget and Financial Office to reimburse the
University for the staff member's time. The mileage fee
should be transmitted to the County or University or
retained by the individual to reimburse the unit or
person providing the transportation.
When served with a subpoena to appear or provide
records, either for deposition or trial, staff members
are obliged to comply subject to the distance
limitations set forth below.
D. Travel Limitations
1. Depositions
The deposition of a non-party witness may take
place at a place not more than 75 miles from his
or her residence, or within the County where the
action is pending so long as it is held within
150 miles of the residence of the witness, unless
the court orders otherwise.
2. Trial
A non-party witness may be subpoenaed to appear
at the trial anywhere in the State of California.
The witness is required to attend at the time
appointed.
E. Release from Serving
Should there be extenuating circumstances that would
make it detrimental for the staff member to give a
deposition or appear as a witness, the County Director
or Statewide Special Program or Project Director should
consult with the Office of the Assistant Vice President,
which in turn will contact the General Counsel, if
necessary, to determine if there is a means for seeking
a continuance or release from the subpoena.
F. Out of State Service
Outside of California, staff members may serve as an
expert witness for a fee provided it is on vacation time
as approved by the appropriate administrator.
IV. LAND CONDEMNATION CASES
The following (Title 18, Section 283, United States Code)
applies to situations where County staff are asked to testify
on land condemnation cases in which the Federal Government
is involved:
"Whoever, being an officer or employee of the United
States or any department or agency thereof, or of the
Senate or House of Representatives, acts as an agent or
attorney for prosecuting any claim against the United
States, or aids or assists in the prosecution or support
of any such claim otherwise than in the proper discharge
of his official duties, or receives any gratuity, or any
share of or interest in any such claim in consideration
of assistance in the prosecution of such claim, shall be
fined not more than $10,000 or imprisoned not more than
one year, or both.
"Federal land condemnation cases represent an activity
of the United States within the meaning of the quoted
law and testimony as to the value of land may be within
the scope of aiding or assisting in a claim against the
United States.
"Since Extension employees are under cooperative
appointment and serve as representatives of the U.S.
Department of Agriculture, it would not be proper for
these employees to aid or assist in a claim against the
United States.
"When employees are subpoenaed to testify in Federal
land condemnation proceedings, they are required to do
so. In so far as the court will permit, they should
testify only as to matters of fact. As joint employees
with responsibilities to the Federal and State
Governments, they should not make soil surveys or
otherwise attempt to prepare themselves better to
represent specific land owners' interests after they
know land is involved in Federal condemnation
proceedings. Subpoenaed employees should inform the
U.S. Attorney handling the Government case of that fact
and the nature of testimony they expect to receive."
--
January 1991